Bathtub or shower in your renovation? Pros and cons of each option

When you think about an integral reform and the time comes to consider how you want your future bathroom, the classic question arises: should I choose a bathtub or a shower tray? The decision depends on many factors. However, the right choice will depend entirely on your available space, your daily habits and your family's needs. If you are lucky enough to have two bathrooms, the ideal would be to combine the two, installing a shower in one and a bathtub in the other. But if you only have one, let's break down the pros and cons of each option to help you decide. The key is to determine which best suits your lifestyle: a quick and efficient ritual or an oasis of relaxation?

The big decision: bathtub or shower

The available infrastructure, structural conditions and realistic budget are crucial when planning your bathroom. Properly measuring the space you have available is an essential step before deciding on a bathtub or shower.

The space factor and design

Space is often the most decisive factor.

• Showers are generally more compact and use less floor space than bathtubs. They are the perfect solution to save space in small bathrooms or bathrooms with unusual floor plans, such as those with sloping ceilings. To allow you to move around comfortably, it is recommended that the width and length of the shower tray be at least 80 cm. In addition, a floor-level shower, integrated with glass partitions and continuous tiles, can make the room appear much larger.
• A bathtub, on the other hand, requires considerably more space. To be able to lie down comfortably, a standard bathtub should be at least 150 cm long and 70 cm wide, although these dimensions may change depending on the model you choose. If you have a large bathroom, a freestanding bathtub can become the focal point, adding a touch of luxury and sophistication.

Lifestyle and comfort

Your daily routine makes all the difference in this choice. If you lead a busy life and need to start your day quickly, a shower is the quickest and most efficient option. However, if you're looking to unwind and relieve stress after a long day, nothing compares to the pleasure of a warm, restorative bath. Bathtubs with whirlpool or Jacuzzi functions can even replace the need to go to a spa.

Advantages and disadvantages of shower trays

The shower tray: speed and savings

The popularity of showers is due to several key benefits. In addition to saving time during the week, showers are notably more environmentally friendly and economical. An average five-minute shower uses only about 40 liters of water, while filling a bathtub can require up to 150 liters. This not only saves you water, but also money.

In terms of safety and accessibility, the shower tray is superior. Floor-level showers (without edges or slopes) facilitate access, eliminate barriers and are ideal for the elderly or people with reduced mobility, preventing falls. If you are looking for a barrier-free solution, you should know that specific minimum dimensions are required, such as 180 x 180 cm for a complete accessible bathroom.

Installation points to consider

While the installation of a shower can be simple, if you want a shower flush with the floor, the complexity increases. This type of design requires more sealing and tiling work compared to installing a bathtub.

Advantages and disadvantages of the bathtub

The bathtub: relaxation and family fun

The bathtub is still the preferred option in many households, especially those with children, as it facilitates hygiene for the little ones and becomes a play space. For adults, a warm bath not only relieves stress, but can also boost the body's natural defenses if you're coming down with a cold. In addition to relaxation, the bathtub offers flexibility, as it allows you to bathe as well as shower.

Space and consumption: the bathtub or shower dilemma

As we have already mentioned, the main drawback of the bathtub is the large space it requires. Another point to consider is maintenance, as bathtubs can be more laborious to clean due to their large surfaces and the accumulation of soap residue.

Long-term value and your final choice

When planning your renovation, think about the value it could have in a future sale. Modern showers can increase the value of your home, especially in urban areas where space savings are vital. However, if your goal is to attract families, having at least one tub or shower - or rather, a bathtub - in the house can make it more attractive.

If your lifestyle is very active, the shower is your best ally. If what you crave is a moment of comfort and relaxation, the bathtub is your choice. Whatever your choice, the decision between bathtub or shower should be based on your priorities of space, use and well-being.

Anyway, we remind you that in Studio by Clikalia we have done hundreds of integral reforms and all kinds of projects, so we know very well what option is best if you are looking for professional advice on this subject.

Do you want us to prepare you aproposal + budget of reform totally free and without obligation? In just a few days we send it to you and you decide. And if you want to know more about bathroom reforms, in our blog you will find more posts similar to this.